In October 2024, Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita issued letters to the sheriffs of Lake and St. Joseph counties, alleging non-compliance with federal immigration authorities. The letters accused these departments of failing to honor U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detainer requests and warned of potential legal action if they did not align with state law by November 8, 2024.
Attorney General’s Allegations
Attorney General Rokita’s letters cited reports from ICE designating the Lake and St. Joseph County Sheriff’s Offices as “non-cooperative.” He asserted that these departments did not notify ICE prior to releasing certain individuals from custody and failed to comply with ICE detainer requests. Rokita emphasized that such actions could undermine public safety and violate Indiana’s anti-sanctuary city statute.
Lake County Sheriff’s Response
At the time of the initial allegations, the Lake County Sheriff’s Office did not publicly respond to Attorney General Rokita’s letter. Recent inquiries indicate that the department continues to review its policies to ensure compliance with both state and federal laws. The Sheriff’s Office maintains that it has always prioritized public safety and will continue to cooperate with federal authorities within the bounds of the law.
Developments in St. Joseph County
In contrast, the St. Joseph County Police Department promptly addressed the Attorney General’s allegations, stating that they do not have policies restricting cooperation with ICE and are in full compliance with state and federal laws. Despite this assertion, Attorney General Rokita filed a lawsuit against St. Joseph County Sheriff William Redman in February 2025, alleging persistent refusal to cooperate with federal immigration authorities.
Statewide Enforcement of Immigration Policies
Attorney General Rokita’s actions are part of a broader initiative to enforce Indiana’s anti-sanctuary city laws. His office has issued similar warnings and taken legal action against other jurisdictions, including Monroe County, to ensure compliance with state statutes mandating cooperation with federal immigration enforcement.
Conclusion
The Lake County Sheriff’s Office acknowledges the Attorney General’s concerns and is committed to ensuring that its policies align with legal requirements. The department emphasizes its dedication to public safety and lawful cooperation with federal authorities. As this situation develops, the Sheriff’s Office will continue to assess and adjust its practices to uphold its commitment to the community and the law.
For continuous updates on this developing story, stay connected with Lake County Florida News.
